Shared Fault In Car Accident Cases | Comparative Negligence

March 8, 2024

Navigating the aftermath of an accident can be an overwhelming experience, especially when you’re dealing with the possibility that you may have played a role in causing it. The question, “What happens if I’m partially at fault for the accident?” is a common concern that many individuals face when considering the pursuit of a personal injury claim. This introductory exploration into the complexities of comparative negligence aims to shed light on how shared fault impacts the legal landscape of personal injury cases.

The concept of comparative negligence acknowledges that accidents are often the result of actions taken by multiple parties. Understanding how this legal doctrine operates and its implications for compensation is important for anyone pursuing a personal injury claim.

In this article, we’ll discuss the intricacies of comparative negligence, exploring how partial fault is assessed, its effect on compensation, and some strategies to safeguard your rights and maximize your claim’s potential. 

Understanding Comparative Negligence

In personal injury law, the concept of comparative negligence is important, especially when an accident isn’t solely caused by one party. This doctrine allows for a more equitable distribution of responsibility and, subsequently, compensation, based on each party’s contribution to the accident. Let’s unpack this principle to understand how it might apply if you find yourself in this situation.

The Basics of Comparative Negligence

Comparative negligence is a legal standard that reduces the claimant’s compensation by the percentage of their fault. For instance, if you were found to be 30% responsible for an accident, your compensation could be reduced by 30%. This approach acknowledges that multiple factors and parties can contribute to an accident.

Types of Comparative Negligence

There are primarily two types of comparative negligence:

  1. Pure Comparative Negligence: Under this system, you can recover damages even if you are 99% at fault, though your compensation will be reduced by your fault percentage. This model is the most lenient towards plaintiffs.
  2. Modified Comparative Negligence: This more common approach sets a threshold, typically 50% or 51%, beyond which you cannot recover any damages. If you’re deemed less at fault than the threshold, you can recover a portion of the damages, reduced by your percentage of fault.

Kentucky is a pure comparative negligence state, while Illinois is a modified comparative negligence state.

Determining Fault

The process of determining fault involves a detailed examination of the accident circumstances, often requiring accident reconstruction specialists, eyewitness testimony, and other evidentiary support. This phase is important, as the allocation of fault impacts the potential compensation.

Impact on Compensation

Understanding the correlation between your degree of fault and your recoverable compensation is important as it may affect the outcome of your case.

Navigating the complexities of comparative negligence requires an understanding of the law and a strategic approach to presenting your case. In the following section, we’ll explore the implications of partial fault on compensation and some steps you can take to ensure your rights are fully protected in the wake of an accident.

The Impact of Partial Fault on Compensation

When an individual is found to be partially at fault in a personal injury case, it can affect the compensation they may receive. This section discusses how partial fault may influence the determination of damages and what claimants can expect in terms of financial recovery.

Proportional Reduction in Damages

Kentucky follows the comparative negligence rule, which means the compensation awarded to a claimant is reduced in proportion to their degree of fault. For example, if a claimant is found to be 20% responsible for an accident and the total damages amount to $100,000, the claimant’s compensation would be reduced by 20%, resulting in an award of $80,000. 

Thresholds and Limits

In states that adhere to a modified comparative negligence system, like Illinois, claimants must be less at fault than a certain threshold, often 50% or 51%, to receive any compensation. If a claimant’s fault exceeds this threshold, they may be barred from recovering any damages. 

Calculating Fault Percentage

The determination of fault percentage is an important aspect of the legal process and involves a thorough analysis of the evidence. Legal professionals and, in some cases, juries examine the circumstances of the accident, including actions taken by all parties involved, to assign a percentage of fault to each. 

Impact on Negotiations

The concept of partial fault also plays a significant role in settlement negotiations. Insurance companies and opposing parties may argue for a higher degree of fault on the claimant’s part to reduce the settlement amount. Skilled negotiation, backed by solid evidence, is important to counter these arguments and secure fair compensation.

Legal Strategy and Representation

Given the complexities involved in cases of partial fault, having experienced legal representation is important. A personal injury attorney can develop a strategy to help minimize the percentage of fault attributed to you, argue for a fair assessment of damages, and navigate the negotiation or trial process to advocate for your best interests.

Future Implications

The determination of partial fault and its impact on compensation can also have long-term implications, especially for severe injuries requiring ongoing medical treatment or resulting in long-term disabilities. Ensuring that future damages are accurately assessed and compensated is an important aspect of a personal injury claim involving partial fault.

Understanding how partial fault affects compensation is important for anyone involved in a personal injury case. It underscores the importance of thorough documentation, evidence gathering, and strategic legal representation to ensure that the compensation received is just and reflective of the true nature of the accident and its impact on the claimant’s life.

Determining Fault in Personal Injury Cases

The process of determining fault in personal injury cases often dictates the outcome of compensation claims. This section explores some of the methodologies and considerations involved in establishing fault.

Gathering Evidence

The initial step in determining fault involves gathering evidence. This may include police reports, eyewitness accounts, photographs of the accident scene and surveillance footage. Each piece of evidence helps provide a factual basis for establishing liability.

The Role of Expert Witnesses

Expert witnesses, such as accident reconstruction specialists, medical professionals, and engineers, may play an important role in complex aspects of a case. Their expertise can clarify the causation, the extent of injuries, and the technical details of an accident.

Legal Standards and Precedents

The application of legal standards and precedents is a fundamental aspect to the fault determination process. Laws vary across jurisdictions, and understanding the specific statutes and case law relevant to the accident’s location is important. Lawyers often reference similar cases, drawing parallels to established legal principles.

Comparative Analysis

Determining fault frequently involves a comparative analysis of each party’s actions leading up to the accident. This includes evaluating the adherence to laws, the reasonableness of the actions under the circumstances, and the direct impact of these actions on the occurrence and severity of the accident.

Contributory Factors

In many cases, multiple contributory factors may be at play when allocating fault. These can include environmental conditions, third-party involvement, and unforeseen events. Assessing the contributory factors and their respective impacts on the accident often requires a detailed investigation and legal understanding.

Negotiation and Litigation

The determination of fault is not only a matter of factual analysis but also a subject of negotiation between the involved parties and their legal representatives. In many cases, fault percentages are negotiated based on the available evidence and legal arguments. If an agreement cannot be reached, the matter may proceed to litigation, where a judge or jury will make the final determination of fault based on the evidence presented.

Importance of Legal Representation

Given the complexities involved in determining fault, skilled legal representation is essential. A knowledgeable personal injury attorney can help navigate the evidentiary requirements, advocate effectively for a fair fault determination, and ensure that your rights are protected throughout the process.

The process of determining fault in personal injury cases is multifaceted, involving a thorough examination of evidence, legal standards, and contributory factors. Understanding this process underscores the importance of gathering evidence and legal guidance in pursuing a personal injury claim.

Protecting Your Rights

After an accident, especially where fault may be shared, it’s important to take steps to protect your legal rights. This section outlines some actions you can take to ensure your interests are safeguarded throughout the claims process.

Actions Post-Accident

Documentation: Take comprehensive notes and photographs at the accident scene. Document your injuries, any damage to property, and the conditions that may have contributed to the accident. 

Seek Medical Attention: Even if your injuries seem minor, it’s beneficial to see a healthcare professional. Medical records will be important in documenting the nature and extent of your injuries.

Legal Considerations

Be Mindful of Statements: Be cautious about what you say to other parties involved in the accident, witnesses, or insurance adjusters. Admitting fault, even casually, can impact your ability to recover compensation.

Understand the Statute of Limitations: Every jurisdiction has specific time limits within which you must file a personal injury claim. Familiarize yourself with these deadlines to ensure you don’t forfeit your right to pursue compensation.

Engaging with Insurance Companies

Review Insurance Policies: Understand the coverage details of your insurance policy, as well as the policies of any other parties involved in the accident. 

Consult Before Accepting Settlements: Insurance companies may offer a quick settlement, which can be appealing but might not fully cover your losses. Consult with a personal injury attorney before accepting any offers to ensure you are fairly compensated.

Seeking Legal Advice

Consult a Personal Injury Attorney: An experienced attorney can provide advice on protecting your rights and maximizing your compensation. They can handle negotiations on your behalf, represent you in court if necessary, and help guide you through the complexities of the legal system.

Understand Your Legal Options: Your attorney can explain your legal options, including the potential for settlement or litigation, and the implications of each. They can also help you understand how your degree of fault might affect your claim.

Long-Term Protection

Keep Detailed Records: Maintain a file of documents related to the accident, including medical bills, correspondence with insurance companies, and any other relevant information. These documents may be used in proving damages and defending your claim.

Monitor Your Recovery: Keep track of your recovery progress and any ongoing health issues related to the accident. Ongoing medical documentation can support claims for additional compensation if your injuries lead to long-term health problems.

Protecting your rights after an accident where fault may be shared involves careful documentation, cautious communication, understanding legal and insurance complexities, and seeking professional legal advice. Taking these steps can help ensure that your interests are fully protected and that you receive the compensation you deserve for your injuries and losses.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is comparative negligence?

Comparative negligence is a legal principle used to allocate fault among parties involved in an accident. It reduces the claimant’s compensation by their percentage of fault in causing the accident.

2. Can I still receive compensation if I’m partially at fault?

Yes, under comparative negligence laws, you can still receive compensation even if you’re partially at fault, but the amount may be reduced based on your percentage of responsibility.

3. How is fault percentage determined in an accident?

Fault percentage is determined through a thorough analysis of evidence such as police reports and eyewitness accounts. Legal and insurance professionals evaluate this information to assign a percentage of fault to each party.

4. What should I do after an accident if I think I’m partially at fault?

Ensure everyone’s safety, call emergency services, document the scene, seek medical attention, and avoid admitting fault. It’s also beneficial to consult with a personal injury attorney to understand your legal options.

5. How does partial fault affect negotiations with insurance companies?

Partial fault can lead to reduced settlement offers from insurance companies. An experienced attorney can help negotiate a fair settlement that considers your degree of fault and the extent of your damages.

6. What is the statute of limitations for filing a personal injury claim?

The statute of limitations varies by jurisdiction but generally ranges from one to four years from the date of the accident. It’s important to file your claim within this period to preserve your right to compensation. Learn more about Kentucky Statute of Limitations.

7. Can I handle a personal injury claim on my own if I’m partially at fault?

While it’s legally possible to represent yourself, navigating the complexities of personal injury law and comparative negligence can be challenging. Professional legal representation can help increase your chances of a favorable outcome.

8. Should I accept a quick settlement offer if I’m partially at fault?

It’s advisable to consult with an attorney before accepting any settlement offers, especially if you’re partially at fault. An attorney can help assess whether the offer adequately covers your damages and advise on negotiation strategies.

9. How can I prove the other party’s fault in an accident?

Proving fault involves collecting evidence such as photographs, videos and eyewitness statements. An attorney can help gather and present this evidence effectively.


Navigating the complexities of personal injury law, especially when partial fault is involved, can be challenging. Understanding comparative negligence and its impact on compensation is important for anyone involved in an accident where fault may be shared.

It’s important to remember that even if you bear some responsibility for an accident, you may still be entitled to compensation. Consult with a knowledgeable personal injury attorney who can help advocate on your behalf.

Legal professionals who specialize in personal injury law can offer the support, guidance, and representation you need to achieve a fair outcome. Remember, the goal is not only to seek compensation but also to ensure justice and accountability for all parties involved.

If you’ve been involved in an accident and are struggling with the complexities of determining fault and understanding your rights, remember that you don’t have to navigate this challenging path alone. Saladino & Schaaf is here to provide the guidance and support you need.

Our team of personal injury attorneys are experienced in handling cases where fault may be shared. We’ll ensure that your voice is heard and your rights are protected. We understand the complexities of personal injury law and are committed to seeking the compensation you deserve.

Don’t let uncertainty and the stress of legal proceedings overwhelm you. Schedule a free consultation with Saladino & Schaaf today. Let us help you on your journey to recovery and resolution.




To reach a trusted member of our team, contact us by calling:


Shared Fault Car Accident - Comparative Negligence




To reach a trusted member of our team, contact us by calling:


Meet Our Team

Saladino & Schaaf, PLLC is dedicated to providing high quality, aggressive legal representation to victims of personal injury and wrongful death. Since 1984, this firm and its predecessors have had one goal in mind – to help the victims of personal injury put the pieces of their lives back together.

Areas of Practice

Car Accidents learn more
Semi-Truck Wrecks learn more
Motorcycle Wrecks learn more
Workplace Injuries learn more
Hospital Negligence learn more
Nursing Home Neglect learn more
Premises Liability learn more
River Injuries / Jones Act learn more
Defective Products learn more
Prescription Drugs learn more

Request Your Free Consultation

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Latest Firm News

Call Today For
Free Consultation:
(270) 444-0406